The Eligible Boys of Fantasy Summer

compiled by Commisioner Dale

Dollar values are taken from the Rotoworld.com Baseball 2004 Reference Guide and reflect the average expected value in a 5x5 Rotisserie auction.

Rosters are accurate as of 3/16/04. Moves made thereafter may not be reflected below.

* Non-roster invitee (ed: Actual Draft Positions to follow. I'm busy with real life, sort of)

CATCHER

  • Jorge Posada NYY $22
  • Jason Varitek BOS $14
  • Mike Lieberthal PHI $11
  • Ramon Hernandez SAN $9
  • Johnny Estrada ATL $8
  • Eli Marrero (1b, of) ATL $8
  • Miguel Olivo CSX $6
  • Michael Barrett CHC $6
  • Brad Ausmus HOU $4
  • Bengie Molina ANA $2
  • Jose Molina ANA $2
  • Ben Davis SEA $2
  • Dan Wilson SEA $2
  • Greg Myers TOR $2
  • Mike Matheny STL $2
  • Doug Mirabelli BOS $1
  • Sandy Alomar Jr. CSX $1
  • John Flaherty NYY $1
  • Kevin Cash TOR $1
  • Eddie Perez ATL $1


  • Paul Bako CHC $1
  • Raul Chavez HOU $1
  • Todd Pratt PHI $1
  • Miguel Ojeda SAN $1
  • Chris Widger STL $1
  • Wil Nieves ANA
  • Josh Paul* ANA
  • Andy Dominique BOS
  • Michel Hernandez BOS
  • Kelly Shoppach* BOS
  • Jamie Burke CSX
  • Mike Rivera CSX
  • Sal Fasano* NYY
  • Joe Girardi* NYY
  • Pat Borders* SEA
  • Guillermo Quiroz TOR
  • Fernando Lunar* CHC
  • Jose Reyes* CHC
  • A.J. Hinch* PHI
  • Tom Wilson SAN

FIRST BASE

  • Jason Giambi NYY $32
  • Carlos Delgado TOR $31
  • Jeff Bagwell HOU $27
  • Phil Nevin (of) SAN $22
  • Paul Konerko CSX $20
  • David Ortiz BOS $19
  • John Olerud SEA $14
  • Adam LaRoche ATL $9
  • Travis Lee NYY $5
  • Tony Clark (of) NYY $4


  • Brian Daubach* BOS $1
  • Julio Franco* ATL $1
  • Dave Hansen (2b, 3b) SEA $1
  • Dave McCarty* (of) BOS
  • Ross Gload CSX
  • Mike Hessman (3b) ATL
  • Scott Thorman ATL
  • Phil Hiatt* HOU
  • Shawn Wooten (c) PHI
  • Todd Sears SAN
  • John Gall STL

SECOND BASE

  • Adam Kennedy ANA $15
  • Mark Loretta (ss) SAN $13
  • Orlando Hudson TOR $11
  • Willie Harris (of) CSX $8
  • Pokey Reese BOS $7
  • Todd Walker CHC $6
  • Mark Grudzielanek CHC $5
  • Chase Utley (3b) PHI $3
  • Marlon Anderson STL $3
  • Juan Uribe CSX $2
  • Tomas Perez PHI $1
  • Bo Hart STL $1
  • Cesar Crespo* BOS
  • Andy Phillips NYY
  • Homer Bush* NYY
  • Dave Berg TOR
  • Jesse Garcia ATL
  • Nick Green ATL
  • Richard Lewis ATL
  • Ramon Martinez CHC
  • Alfredo Amezaga ANA

THIRD BASE

  • Alex Rodriguez (ss) NYY $45
  • Eric Hinske TOR $23
  • Morgan Ensberg HOU $22
  • Aramis Ramirez CHC $20
  • Bill Mueller BOS $17
  • Joe Crede CSX $16
  • Placido Polanco (2b) PHI $15
  • Sean Burroughs SAN $15
  • Scott Spiezio (1b, of) SEA $13
  • David Bell PHI $8
  • Russell Branyan* ATL $3
  • Mike Lamb HOU $1
  • Jeff Cirillo SAN $1
  • Kevin Youkilis BOS
  • Greg Dobbs NYY
  • Justin Leone SEA
  • Simon Pond TOR
  • Mike Coolbaugh* HOU
  • Juan Richardson PHI
  • Dallas McPherson ANA

SHORTSTOP

  • Derek Jeter NYY $32
  • Edgar Renteria STL $29
  • Rafael Furcal ATL $23
  • Jimmy Rollins PHI $20
  • David Eckstein ANA $17
  • Rich Aurilia SEA $16
  • Jose Valentin CSX $14
  • Alex S. Gonzalez CHC $11
  • Adam Everett HOU $9
  • Chris Woodward TOR $8
  • Khalil Greene SAN $8
  • Chone Figgins ANA $3
  • Ramon Vasquez SAN $2
  • Chris Gomez TOR $1
  • Rey Ordoņez* SAN $1
  • Tony Womack* STL $1
  • Kelly Dransfeldt* CSX
  • Ramon Santiago SEA
  • Jorge Sequea TOR
  • Wilson Betemit ATL
  • Kelly Johnson ATL
  • Tony Pena ATL
  • Jorge Velandia* ATL
  • Eric Bruntlett HOU
  • Anderson Machado PHI
  • Hector Luna STL

INFIELDERS

  • Mark DeRosa (of) ATL $9
  • Mark Bellhorn (of) BOS $5
  • Enrique Wilson NYY $1
  • Willie Bloomquist SEA $1
  • Jose Vizcaino HOU $1
  • Shane Halter (of) ANA $1
  • Miguel Cairo NYY
  • Terry Shumpert* BOS


  • Tony Womack* BOS
  • Luis Ugueto SEA

Designated Hitter

  • Frank Thomas CSX $21
  • Josh Phelps TOR $17
  • Edgar Martinez SEA $14

OUTFIELD

  • Magglio Ordoņez CSX $32
  • Gary Sheffield NYY $32
  • Brian Giles SAN $31
  • Vernon Wells TOR $30
  • Garret Anderson ANA $27
  • Andruw Jones ATL $27
  • Carlos Lee CSX $26
  • Johnny Damon BOS $24
  • Pat Burrell PHI $24
  • Bernie Williams NYY $24
  • Jim Edmonds STL $22
  • Richard Hidalgo HOU $22
  • Hideki Matsui NYY $22
  • Ryan Klesko (1b) SAN $22
  • Darin Erstad (1b) ANA $19
  • Trot Nixon BOS $19
  • Reggie Sanders STL $19
  • J.D. Drew ATL $18
  • Marlon Byrd PHI $17
  • Kevin Millar (1b) BOS $17
  • Jose Guillen ANA $17
  • Kenny Lofton NYY $17
  • Randy Winn SEA $17
  • Raul Ibanez SEA $16
  • Corey Patterson CHC $16
  • Moises Alou CHC $15
  • Jay Payton SAN $15
  • Tim Salmon ANA $15
  • Ellis Burks BOS $12
  • Frank Catalanotto (1b) TOR $12
  • Craig Biggio HOU $10
  • Aaron Rowand CSX $9
  • Xavier Nady SAN $8
  • Reed Johnson TOR $7
  • Gabe Kapler BOS $7
  • Terrence Long SAN $6
  • Timo Perez CSX $5
  • Alexis Rios TOR $5
  • Jason Lane (1b) HOU $4
  • Ricky Ledee PHI $3
  • Jeff DaVanon ANA $3
  • Todd Hollandsworth (1b) CHC $2


  • Jeremy Reed CSX $1
  • John Mabry* STL $1
  • Kerry Robinson SAN $1
  • Brian Buchanan (1b) SAN $1
  • Doug Glanville PHI $1
  • Ruben Sierra NYY $1
  • Quinton McCracken SEA $1
  • Chad Hermansen* TOR $1
  • Gary Matthews Jr. ATL $1
  • Eric Owens* SEA $1
  • Orlando Palmeiro HOU $1
  • Jose Macias CHC $1
  • Tom Goodwin CHC $1
  • Adam Hyzdu* BOS
  • Jeremy Owens* BOS
  • Joe Borchard CSX
  • Bubba Crosby NYY
  • Mike Vento NYY
  • Darren Bragg* NYY
  • Chris Snelling SEA
  • Jamal Strong SEA
  • Howie Clark TOR
  • John-Ford Griffin TOR
  • Gabe Gross TOR
  • Jayson Werth TOR
  • Onil Joseph ATL
  • Ryan Langerhans ATL
  • Jason Dubois CHC
  • Nic Jackson CHC
  • Dave Kelton (1b) CHC
  • Trenidad Hubbard* CHC
  • Willy Taveras HOU
  • Ryan Thompson* HOU
  • Jason Michaels PHI
  • Lou Collier* PHI
  • Henri Stanley SAN
  • Eugene Kingsale* SAN
  • Colin Porter STL
  • So Taguchi STL
  • Ray Lankford* STL
  • Greg Vaughn* STL
  • Robb Quinlan ANA
  • Barry Wesson ANA
  • Brian L. Hunter STL

STARTING PITCHER

  • Curt Schilling BOS $33
  • Roy Halladay TOR $30
  • Kerry Wood CHC $27
  • Mike Mussina NYY $26
  • Javier Vazquez NYY $23
  • Kevin Brown NYY $21
  • Esteban Loaiza CSX $20
  • Randy Wolf PHI $20
  • Roger Clemens HOU $19
  • Jose Contreras NYY $18
  • Matt Clement CHC $18
  • Wade Miller HOU $18
  • Greg Maddux CHC $17
  • Freddy Garcia SEA $16
  • Jamie Moyer SEA $16
  • Andy Pettitte HOU $16
  • Jake Peavy SAN $16
  • Jarrod Washburn ANA $15
  • Byung-Hyun Kim BOS $15
  • Russ Ortiz ATL $15
  • Mark Buehrle CSX $14
  • Carlos Zambrano CHC $14
  • Vincente Padilla PHI $14
  • Derek Lowe BOS $13
  • Eric Milton PHI $13


  • Woody Williams STL $13
  • Ted Lilly TOR $12
  • Adam Eaton SAN $11
  • Kelvim Escobar ANA $11
  • Brett Myers PHI $11
  • Gil Meche SEA $10
  • Tim Redding HOU $10
  • David Wells SAN $10
  • Brian Lawrence SAN $9
  • John Lackey ANA $9
  • Tim Wakefield BOS $9
  • Ryan Franklin SEA $9
  • Jeff Suppan STL $9
  • John Thomson ATL $9
  • Miguel Batista TOR $8
  • Horacio Ramirez ATL $6
  • Jon Lieber NYY $6
  • Ismael Valdes SAN $4
  • Ramon Ortiz ANA $4
  • John Garland CSX $4
  • Pat Hentgen TOR $4
  • Chris Carpenter STL $2
  • Paul Byrd ATL $1
  • Jason Marquis STL $1
  • Danny Wright CSX $1

SPOT STARTER/LONG RELIEVER

  • Rafael Soriano SEA $14
  • Orlando Hernandez NYY $7
  • Juan Cruz ATL $5
  • Dan Haren STL $2
  • Bronson Arroyo BOS $2
  • Ramiro Mendoza BOS $1
  • Aaron Sele ANA $1
  • Felix Heredia NYY $1
  • Josh Towers TOR $1
  • Brandon Duckworth HOU $1
  • Amaury Telemaco PHI $1
  • Sterling Hitchcock SAN $1
  • Neal Cotts CSX
  • Jon Rauch CSX
  • Scott Schoeneweis CSX
  • Ryan Dempster CHC
  • Jeriome Robertson HOU
  • Jason Simontacchi STL

RELIEF PITCHER

  • Mariano Rivera NYY $30
  • Trevor Hoffman SAN $25
  • Damaso Marte CSX $23
  • Francisco Rodriguez ANA $12
  • Justin Speier TOR $11
  • LaTroy Hawkins CHC $10
  • Aquilino Lopez TOR $9
  • Scott Williamson BOS $9
  • Brendan Donnelly ANA $7
  • Kerry Ligtenberg TOR $7
  • Billy Koch CSX $7
  • Kyle Farnsworth CHC $6
  • Brad Lidge HOU $5
  • Tom Gordon NYY $4
  • Chris Reitsma ATL $4
  • Scot Shields ANA $4
  • Julio Mateo SEA $3
  • Terry Adams TOR $2
  • Rod Beck SAN $2
  • Rheal Cormier PHI $2
  • Alan Embree BOS $2
  • Shigetoshi Hasegawa SEA $2
  • Mike Timlin BOS $2
  • Paul Quantrill NYY $2
  • Gabe White NYY $1
  • Ben Weber ANA $1
  • Cliff Politte CSX $1
  • Antonio Osuna SAN $1
  • Scott Linebrink SAN $1

  • Jason Kershner TOR $1
  • Antonio Alfonseca ATL $1
  • Will Cunnane ATL $1
  • Kevin Gryboski ATL $1
  • Trey Hodges ATL $1
  • Mike Remlinger CHC $1
  • Roberto Hernandez PHI $1
  • Tim Worrell PHI $1
  • Kelly Wunsch CSX
  • Shingo Takatsu CSX
  • Steve Karsay NYY
  • Ron Villone SEA
  • Valerio de los Santos TOR
  • Armando Almanza ATL
  • Jaret Wright ATL
  • Darren Holmes ATL
  • Kent Mercker CHC
  • Dan Miceli HOU
  • Kirk Saarloos HOU
  • David Coggin PHI
  • Bud Smith PHI
  • Victor Alvarez PHI
  • Akinori Otsuka SAN
  • Jay Witasick SAN
  • Cal Eldred STL
  • Ray King STL
  • Steve Kline STL
  • Kiko Calero STL

PITCHERS

  • Garrett Stephenson STL $1
  • Derrick Turnbow ANA $1
  • Todd Wellemeyer CHC $1
  • Steve Andrade ANA
  • Tim Bittner ANA
  • Kevin Gregg ANA
  • Steve Green ANA
  • Bobby Jenks ANA
  • Greg Jones ANA
  • Chris Bootcheck ANA
  • Jake Woods ANA
  • Rich Fischer ANA
  • Edwin Almonte BOS
  • Colter Bean BOS
  • Nick Bierbrodt BOS
  • Jamie Brown BOS
  • Lenny Dinardo BOS
  • Jerome Gamble BOS
  • Reynaldo Garcia BOS
  • Tim Hamulack BOS
  • Mark Malaska BOS
  • Anastacio Martinez BOS
  • Phil Seibel BOS
  • Jason Shiell BOS
  • Bryan Hebson BOS
  • John Burkett BOS
  • Scott Sauerbeck BOS
  • Bobby M. Jones* BOS
  • Jon Adkins CSX
  • Felix Diaz CSX
  • Matt Ginter CSX
  • Jason Grilli CSX
  • Gary Majewski CSX
  • David Sanders CSX
  • Vic Darensbourg* CSX
  • Mike Jackson* CSX
  • Jose Santiago* CSX
  • Josh Stewart* CSX
  • Jorge DePaula NYY
  • Alex Graman NYY
  • Sam Marsonek NYY
  • Scott Proctor NYY
  • Ramon Ramirez NYY
  • Donovan Osborne* NYY
  • Cha Seung Baek SEA
  • Kevin Jarvis SEA
  • Aaron Looper SEA
  • Bobby Madritsch SEA
  • Clint Nageotte SEA
  • J.J. Putz SEA
  • Aaron Taylor SEA
  • Matt Thornton SEA

  • Terry Mulholland* SEA
  • Mike Myers* SEA
  • Jason Arnold TOR
  • Vinnie Chulk TOR
  • Bob File TOR
  • Jesse Harper TOR
  • Dustin McGowan TOR
  • Justin Miller TOR
  • Francisco Rosario TOR
  • Bruce Chen* TOR
  • Jayson Durocher* TOR
  • Andy Pratt ATL
  • Tim Drew* ATL
  • Ryan Glynn* ATL
  • C.J. Nitkowski* ATL
  • Francis Beltran CHC
  • Sergio Mitre CHC
  • Andy Pratt CHC
  • Jimmy Anderson* CHC
  • Juan Pena* CHC
  • Jamey Wright* CHC
  • Brandon Backe HOU
  • Mike Gallo HOU
  • Ricky Stone HOU
  • Brian Moehler HOU
  • Taylor Buchholz HOU
  • Jared Fernandez* HOU
  • Geoff Geary PHI
  • Josh Hancock PHI
  • Eric Junge PHI
  • Ryan Madson PHI
  • Cole Hamels* PHI
  • Keith Bucktrot* PHI
  • Gavin Floyd* PHI
  • Ryan Howard* PHI
  • Jason Szuminski SAN
  • Kevin Walker SAN
  • Ben Howard SAN
  • Dennis Tankersley* SAN
  • Rick Ankiel STL
  • Jimmy Journell STL
  • Mike Lincoln STL
  • Luis Martinez STL
  • Chris Narveson STL
  • Rhett Parrott STL
  • Josh Pearce STL
  • Evan Rust STL
  • Jason Ryan STL
  • Julian Tavarez STL
  • Adam Wainwright STL
  • Lance Painter STL
  • Russ Springer STL
  • Gene Stechschulte STL
  • Alan Benes* STL

Owners, Teams, and Reserved players

Each owner was allowed to reserve 4 players from their team's Roster prior to the assembly of the draft pool. These players could consist of:

The remainder of the team's roster went into the draft pool as described above.

The reserves were:

(in draft order, with notes from the Commish)

BOSTON RED SOX

Jim Lowder

  • ss Nomar Garciaparra BOS $34
  • OF Manny Ramirez BOS $33
  • SP Pedro Martinez BOS $37
  • RP Keith Foulke BOS $34

Reserves (comparison only): $138*

*plus $45 for A-Rod in the first round makes $183. If we were using $275 budgets, the Bosox would be in a world of hurt, trying to fill out 18 positions on their roster with less than $100 left. That's an average of just over $5 per position. Ouch!




HOUSTON ASTROS

Andy Baker

  • 2b Jeff Kent HOU $28
  • OF Lance Berkman HOU $34
  • SP Roy Oswalt HOU $29
  • RP Octavio Dotel HOU $33

Reserves (comparison only): $124

CHICAGO CUBS

Leon Sniegowski/Barb Turk

  • 1b Derrek Lee CHC $24
  • OF Sammy Sosa CHC $30
  • SP Mark Prior CHC $36
  • RP Joe Borowski CHC $22

Reserves (comparison only): $112


ST. LOUIS CARDINALS

Jeff Wirch/Tim Mattner

  • 3b Scott Rolen STL $29
  • OF Albert Pujols (1b) STL $40
  • SP Matt Morris STL $22
  • RP Jason Isringhausen STL $26

Reserves (comparison only): $117


ATLANTA BRAVES

David Eckelberry

  • 2b Marcus Giles ATL $27
  • OF Chipper Jones ATL $28
  • SP Mike Hampton ATL $10
  • RP John Smoltz ATL $32

Reserves (comparison only): $97


ANAHEIM ANGELS

Dale Donovan

  • 3b Troy Glaus ANA $25
  • OF Vlad Guerrero ANA $38
  • SP Bartolo Colon ANA $22
  • RP Troy Percival ANA $27

    Reserves (comparison only): $112

PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES

Rich Baker

  • 1b Jim Thome PHI $29
  • OF Bobby Abreu PHI $32
  • SP Kevin Millwood PHI $19
  • RP Billy Wagner PHI $34

Reserves (comparison only): $114

SEATTLE MARINERS

Scott Magner

  • 2b Bret Boone SEA $27
  • OF Ichiro SEA $28
  • SP Joel Pineiro SEA $19
  • RP Eddie Guardado SEA $10

Reserves (comparison only): $84*

*note that Guardado's price is based on his being a set-up man, not the Seattle closer now that Kaz Sasaki is back in Japan.

Back to Roto Central